Dining Guide: 22 Tasty Restaurants in Mentor and Mentor-on-the-Lake

Editor's Note: This article was published in October 2023. Prices and menu items are subject to change.

Blue Fin Hibachi and Sushi Bar

Why we love it: At this casual Asian fusion hibachi and sushi bar, you’ll discover the tasty aforementioned staples, along with soup, salad, tempura sushi and a bento box lunch menu in a simple upbeat ambiance. Try this: A sushi and sashimi lunch ($18) with four pieces of nigiri, one maki roll and four pieces of sashimi. 8820 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-290-7383, bluefinmentoroh.com

Billy's A Cappelli Martini Bar

Why we love it: Known for specialty martinis, this cocktail lounge on Route 306 offers more than 50 apps, salads, burgers and entrees that are perfect drinking companions. Try this: Snack on Billy's Brie ($12), a simple presentation of baked cheese, cranberry, drizzled raspberries, crostini, French baguette and apples. 7338 Industrial Park, Mentor, 440-585-8815, billysacappellimartinibar.com

Campola’s Italian Bistro

Why we love it: Regulars visit this
family-style restaurant and patio with a traditional scratch kitchen multiple nights a week. “The ambiance is almost like you’re at a friend’s house having dinner,” says owner Nikki Campola of the 16-year-old restaurant with lots of charm. Try this: The Penne Florentine ($22) is crafted with homemade garlic oil sauce, fresh sausage, spinach and Parmesan cheese with roasted pine nuts. 7224 Center St., Mentor, campolas.com, 440-290-8676

Dynamite Dawgs

Why we love it: Since opening in 2020, this simple, fair-inspired joint has developed a following around its Brats, hand-cut fries (loaded or regular), desserts (think deep-fried Oreos) and, of course, hot dogs. Try this: The signature Dynamite Dawg ($6) is topped with Coney chili sauce, nacho cheese, diced onion and grilled bacon. 6312 Center St. Suite A, Mentor, 440-290-0286, dynamitedawgs.com

Issho Ni Poke Bar

Why we love it: This small, bright, locally owned spot whips up sushi burritos, bubble tea and other Hawaiian-Japanese fusion cuisine — and best yet, has a build your own poke bowl option. Try this: Create your own poke bowl with one protein ($13.50) and pile on unlimited toppings. 9570 Mentor Ave, Mentor, 440-754-8204, isshonipokebar.com

Happy Moose Bar & Grill

Why we love it: Who doesn't love a no-frills, familiar sports bar? This bright, friendly pub with wooden decor on Route 306 and Route 2 features the usual suspects: wings, burgers and other bar food. With ample bar and table seating and tons of TVs, you can almost always find a seat for the big game at this chill place to relax with friends. Looking to throw a party? The covered, 70-seat patio can be rented for events. Try this: Dive into the homemade Buffalo chicken dip ($12), served with tortilla chips. 7693 Reynolds Road, Mentor, 440-953-9464, happymoosebarandgrill.com/mentor

The Hooley Pub & Kitchen

Why we love it: Though it has two other Northeast Ohio locations, this fun pub is headquartered in Mentor. In addition to Irish-leaning fare, pizza, wings, 20 specialty cocktails and 32 craft beers on tap, the gastropub has made its name on being a community gathering space for trivia, live performances and games.  Try this: Many diners can't bring themselves to use the phrase "boneless wings." Luckily, you don't have to when ordering hand-cut Hooley Hunks ($14.50) with spicy, creamy firecracker ranch. 7861 Reynolds Road, Mentor, 440-942-6611, 1funpub.com

Longo's Pizza

Why we love it: The family run spot has been Mentor's independent pizza choice for 55 years, opening in 1969. Try this: The menu of gluten-free pizza, chicken Parmesan, pasta and other delicious items are godsends for those with dietary restrictions. 8907 Mentor Ave., 440-974-8282; 7314 Lakeshore Blvd., 440-946-8222, longospizza.com

Maki Mentor

Why we love it: In addition to savory Asian fusion such as hibachi, sushi and noodles, this relaxed, modern joint whips up fruity bubble tea in every color of the rainbow. Try this: The salmon hibachi dinner ($23) is grilled and served with veggies and rice. 9582 Diamond Center Drive, Mentor, 440-853-8685, facebook.com/makimentor

Mama Roberto’s Italian Restaurant

Why we love it: The 26-year family-run spot touts its “original Cleveland-style pizza” and other Italian dishes, such as veal and seafood. Try this: Opt for a classic chicken marsala ($24) with mushroom marsala wine sauce and a side of pasta. 8658 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-205-8890, mamarobertos.com 

Manhattan Deli

Why we love it: Since 1987, Tim and Siham Shaker have offered a taste of New York City with their menu of Jewish deli, fresh-baked bagel with schmear and diner classics. Try this: The Uptowner ($16.95) stacks corned beef and pastrami. Dip it in some matzo ball soup ($7.50). 8900 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-974-0055, manhattandelimentor.com

Pastina Rustic Italian Kitchen

Why we love it: This modern take on farm-to-table Italian fare focused on locally sourced scratch-made dishes is run by a local family. Try this: Combine health and flavor with the grilled Atlantic salmon ($27) served with herb risotto and orange-fennel salad. 9354 Mentor Ave. # 1, Mentor, 440-255-3117, pastinarusticitalian.com

Market Street Family Restaurant

Why we love it: Find breakfast staples and classic American dishes at this updated family-style restaurant. The large menu of sandwiches, pasta, salads, omelets and other delights satisfy any type of craving. Try this: Start with the fresh, housemade tabbouleh ($5.99) before moving on to a burger, breakfast, seafood and almost anything else. 8450 Market St., Mentor, 440-255-4962, marketstreetmentor.takeout7.com/ourmenu

Malley's Chocolates

Why we love it: The Mentor location, one of four that serve ice cream, carries that classic parlor decor with  old-school booths and '50s-style bar seating. Families enjoy ice cream before taking home treats like truffles, chocolate bars and candies. Try this: Drench your selection from 25 flavors in house-made hot fudge. 8920 Mentor Ave. B, Mentor, 440-974-1440, malleys.com

Ninja Japanese

Why we love it: This Mentor-on-the-Lake spot serves some of Northeast Ohio's best sushi. Try this: The Mentor Lake Special ($28) is a seafood lovers' dream with tempura shrimp, spicy tuna, salmon and yellowtail on top. 7873 Munson Road, Mentor-On-The-Lake, 440-701-8293, ninjainmentor.com

The Indian Kitchen

Why we love it: For authentic Indian flavors with some innovative twists, this classy eatery packs big flavor into biryani, momos, curries, naan and all your Indian favorites. Try this: If you've had your fill of tandoori chicken and goat biryani, try the chicken saag ($16.95), a boneless chicken breast tossed in traditional creamy Indian spinach sauce. 9552 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-650-0060, theindiankitchenmentor.com

Thai Orchid

Why we love it: Don't let the strip mall fool you. Inside you'll find solid curry, rice and noodle dishes as well as seasonal specials. Try this: Add shrimp to the sweet massaman curry ($14.50). 7502 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-942-6752, facebook.com/thaiorchidkitchen

TJ’s on the Avenue 

Why we love it: Owner Cameron Pulling  says, “We have a lot of dishes we created in-house that the community is very fond of, like the Chicken Madison.” The Pulling family has been cooking up homemade Italian dishes and daily made pasta, bread and sauces since 1992. Some staff members have been there for more than 30 years. Try this: “Chicken Madison ($19.29) is my go-to dish to recommend,” says Pulling. Breaded chicken sauteed with fresh mushrooms and a white wine sauce, topped with melted provolone and cheddar, finished freshly cut scallions. 7485 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-953-5959, tjsontheavenue.com

Trios Italian Grille & Catering

Why we love it: Three families came together to whip up a modern concept focusing on traditional Italian favorites. Their combined heritage and travels inspired the fresh menu of pasta, pizza, calzones, strombolis and specialty dishes. Try this: Choose from the carnivore ($14-$18) calzone or stromboli packed with all the meats: pepperoni, sausage, soppressata, pepperoncini, ricotta and provolone cheese. 7537 Mentor Ave. #23, Mentor, 440-571-5306, triositaliangrille.com

Yours Truly

Why we love it: This beloved spot is part of a local chain purveying comforting American fare in a friendly homey atmosphere. Stop by for breakfast, lunch or dinner for a three-egg omelet, fire-grilled burger, Monte Cristo or a signature cocktail. Try this: Who doesn’t love a place with an all-day breakfast? We love the Killit Skillet ($12) with two eggs, bacon, sausage, golden hash browns with onion, green pepper, mixed cheese and toasted ciabatta. 280 Center St., Mentor, 440-255-3003, ytr.com/mentor

Zappitelli’s

Why we love it: For over 35 years and counting, this self-described Old World Italian restaurant whips up all the flavors of Italy through family recipes. Stop by for good old-fashioned mom-and-pop traditional dishes, including homemade pizza, pasta, subs and specialty dishes made with the fan-favorite sauce. Try this: You can’t beat potato gnocchi ($18.50) made from scratch. 9570 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-352-1185, zappitellismentor.com

For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.

Cleveland Magazine is also available in print, publishing 12 times a year with immersive features, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.