Flats Hotel Development Falls Through
Metroparks seeks a new project partner after the Cleveland Milling Company redevelopment was called off.
by Ken Prendergast, NEOTrans | Nov. 19, 2026 | 1:30 PM
Courtesy NEO Trans
This article was published through an exclusive content-sharing agreement with neo-trans.blog.
Since last week, demolition work by a Cleveland Metroparks contractor got underway to take down the former Catanese Classic Seafood buildings. 1600 Merwin Ave., next to the Cuyahoga River and the Center Street swing bridge in Cleveland’s Flats.
It looked like riverfront development was going according to plan.
That was until the Metroparks’ Board of Trustees agenda hit the parks’ website this week. It revealed that a deal to revitalize the neighboring former Grain Craft flour mill, 1636-1656 Merwin, into a hotel with restaurants and commercial spaces called the Cleveland Milling Company redevelopment was off.
Now, the fate of the mill property will rest with a new sealed bid process, authorized by Metroparks’ board action today. It also set into motion a process of determining if any of the affected properties on the Columbus Road Peninsula are excess and unnecessary, setting the stage for a possible future sale.
Last year, the Metroparks selected through a request for proposals (RFP) a development partnership of hotelier Ceres Enterprises of Westlake and LaPine Development LLC of Gates Mills (CLD) to redevelop the Grain Craft mill, parts of which date to 1882. Metroparks would have retained ownership of the property.
“After many months of arduous negotiations and efforts, which include CLD successfully securing historic tax credits to financially aid in redeveloping the properties, on Sept. 16, 2026, CLD notified Cleveland Metroparks that it was withdrawing from the redevelopment project, and Cleveland Metroparks thereafter provided formal notice terminating the MOU,” Metroparks board documents show.
CLD was one of two respondents to the Metroparks’ 2025 RFP. The other wasn’t publicly identified. CLD planned the $61.6 million Cleveland Milling Company redevelopment and things appeared to be moving forward with little trouble.
For example, by last December, $10.3 million in federal historic tax credits were secured and the State of Ohio added $5 million in additional historic tax credits. CLD said in its application to the state that its contribution would put 100 percent of the project’s financing in place.
The first phase of redevelopment of the mill’s multiple structures totaling 120,000 square feet was due to start in January 2027 and be completed about 2.5 years thereafter.
“No comment,” said Ceres Enterprises’ Executive Vice President of Marketing Frank Crisafi in a brief telephone conversation on why the deal fell through. “There’s lots of moving pieces in this.”
Members of CLD had partnered with each other before on a complex redevelopment project. They converted two former 60-year-old NASA office buildings in suburban Fairview Park into The Orbit Hotel, Trademark Collection by Wyndham, and Centaur market-rate apartments.
Metroparks had considered demolishing some or all of the flour mill in early 2025 when it won an Ohio Brownfield Remediation Program Grant in the amount of over $2.2 million, leveraged by $1.8 million in Metroparks funds. But it was convinced to use that funding as part of the capital stack for cleaning up and redeveloping the mill site.
“In the aftermath of CLD withdrawing, Cleveland Metroparks has continued to explore other avenues for redevelopment of the properties, including sale of the properties,” the Metroparks’ board documents add. Up to $2.7 million in Brownfield funds could be redirected to the new owner.
Those documents say that the Metroparks doesn’t need all of the former mill properties, as well as those that were previously owned by Marlin Investment Group LLC which is owned by the Catanese family. Catanese Classic Seafood leased the property from Marlin before relocating to Collinwood.
“Cleveland Metroparks staff recommends that Cleveland Metroparks explore a fee sale of the properties through a sealed bid process, while retaining a trail easement on the properties to preserve public access to the riverfront,” board documents continue.
The Metroparks board noted that it also could reject any or all of the bid responses. Metroparks paid $3.5 million to acquire the former flour mill properties and $4 million to purchase Marlin’s properties.
For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.
Cleveland Magazine is also available in print, featuring immersive stories, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.
Ken Prendergast, NEOTrans
Ken Prendergast is a local professional journalist who loves and cares about Cleveland, its history and its development. He has worked as a journalist for more than three decades for publications such as NEOtrans, Sun Newspapers, Ohio Passenger Rail News, Passenger Transport, and others. He also provided consulting services to transportation agencies, real estate firms, port authorities and nonprofit organizations. He runs NEOtrans Blog covers the Greater Cleveland region’s economic, development, real estate, construction and transportation news since 2011. His content is published on Cleveland Magazine as part of an exclusive sharing agreement.
Trending
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
