Food & Drink

Cocky's Bagels Sets Up Shop In North Olmsted

In honor of the popular food truck opening a brick-and-mortar space, we share our three favorite sandwiches.

by Alexandra Tinline | Sep. 10, 2019 | 12:00 PM

Build it and they will come. That’s been the idea behind Cocky’s Bagels, which started out as a food truck back in 2017.

With a menu based on massive bagel sandwiches, owners Keene Cockburn, Kevin Cockburn and Natalie Bata have created a following of loyal customers who seek out their towering inventions for a hearty lunch or filling late-night snack.

In June, the trio parlayed their success into a brick-and-mortar spot in North Olmsted. Here are three of our fave bagel bites.

Cocky’s Bagel, $8

The sandwich that inspired it all comes loaded with grilled turkey, salami, a fried egg, melted provolone, lettuce, tomato and onion on an everything bagel. You’ll get a hit of heat thanks to Cocky’s sauce, a secret spicy aioli. “It’s a special one for me,” says Keene Cockburn. “I was making this every day in high school and that’s when I decided I needed to do something with it.” 

Love Is All You Need Cocky's

Love Is All You Need, $9

Inspired by Cavs guard Kevin Love, this lighter breakfast sandwich features an everything bagel with fried egg, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and chipotle ranch. You can add turkey for $2. “The really cool thing about this bagel is that part of the proceeds from the sale actually go towards [Kevin Love’s] mental health fund,” says Bata. 

Cocky's Avo Toast

Avocado Toast Bagel, $9

One of the shop’s “topless bagel” options, this take on the trendy avocado toast starts with just one half of an everything bagel. Freshly smashed avocado is layered with a fried egg and tomato and then drizzled with Cocky’s sauce. “It lets you be healthy,” says Bata. “The combination of ingredients works well.”

Get the Latest in Your Inbox

Whether you're looking for daily news bites, the latest bites or bite-sized adventures, the Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter experiences have something for everyone.