13 Record Stores to Check Out in Greater Cleveland

Interest in vinyl has continued to soar in Cleveland and across the country, but collectors like it for different reasons. For some, like Bridget Ginley, the search for that one record she has wanted for years is just as important as the score.

“We’re Midwesterners,” she says. “We like a good hunt.”

Ginley, the host of Erie Effusion on WRUW-FM 91.1, owns a couple thousand records with her partner. She cycled through the different formats — tape, CD, download — before coming back to vinyl. There’s something about that sound that isn’t present in other formats; and then there’s the aesthetic.

“It’s like a piece of art, to find the condition it’s in and wonder where it’s been,” she says.

The spotlight on vinyl is perhaps brightest on April 12, when many independent stores celebrate Record Store Day. Consider this your map to Cleveland’s record store scene.  

Bent Crayon
Tucked inside 78th Street Studios is Bent Crayon, John Cellura's shop that has specialized in eclectic, curated new releases since 1995. 1305 W. 80th St., Suite 216, Cleveland, 216-221-9200, bentcrayon.com 

Blackbird Records
While the store named after the Beatles' song most recently opened a third storefront in suburban Medina, Blackbird Records had already established itself with locations in Wooster and Mansfield. Expect a mix of new and used wax. Need a turntable, some rock art for your wall or an autographed collectible? The store has you covered, says owner Joshua Lehman. Various locations, instagram.com/blackbird_records_wooster

Blue Arrow Records
The Waterloo neighborhood mainstay found its niche and stayed true to it: used rock, R&B, country and more. “We have a few new releases, but if they want vintage, they come this way,” owner Pete Gulyas says. If you’re lucky, you’ll also get to pet a cat or two. 16001 Waterloo Road, Cleveland, 216-486-2415, bluearrowrecords.com

The Current Year
Perhaps best known nationally for its “Parma for Pavement” event, the store has an eclectic mix of vinyl. Find rock records, but also things off the beaten path, with a focus on mood music, exotica and lounge. 5580 Ridge Road, Parma, 440-879-7227, thecurrentyear.com

Hanson Records
Much like Oberlin itself, Hanson Records is just a little bit out there. The store stocks classic rock but also has a deep catalog of jazz, experimental and noise. The hardcore collectors who want to spend a bit more will surely find something on their display walls. 25 1/2 W. College St., Oberlin, 440-467-0855, hansonrecords.net

Hausfrau Record Shop
After years in Gordon Square next to the Capitol Theatre, Hausfrau recently moved to the expansive Visible Voice bookstore's new home in Ohio City. Don't let the small collection fool you. The quality of the punk, metal, R&B, jazz, world, experimental and noise records is remarkably high and as eclectic as it sounds. It's also really nice to literally go through an entire shop’s inventory in one visit. 4601 Lorain Ave., Upstairs, Cleveland, 216-394-5171, instagram.com/hausfraurecordshop

Hollow Bone Records
A strip mall in suburban Akron is not supposed to include a good record store, but Hollow Bone challenges that notion. The Fairlawn shop, open since 2015, has a large selection of new and used rock, jazz and other records ­— including some local picks — along with turntables. Don’t miss the discount section either.  2721 W. Market St., Fairlawn, 234-334-7484, hollowbonerecords.com

Late Nite Records
Ever get the itch to shuffle through records but all the stores are closed? Late Nite Records has you covered. Open until midnight every night, the new-ish Clark-Fulton shop has a variety of rock, hip-hop, electronic and more to peruse. If you’re lucky, you'll browse while a DJ is spinning. 2602 Walton Ave., Cleveland, 440-915-1411, facebook.com/lateniterecordscleveland

Mistake by the Lake Records
A relative new kid on the block, the West Side shop has an ever-growing mix of used records and vintage media (think cassettes and VHS). But the real attraction is its selection of new Cleveland music. “We try to focus on local, be it cassette tape, vinyl or whatever format they put it out on,” says owner Andrew Kirschner. 6502 Lorain Ave., Cleveland, 440-317-0317, mbtlrecords.com

My Mind’s Eye Records
With a large collection of new records of all genres, your best bet to find a modern record is here. The store, next to the former Barry Buick, also has a quality used section. Note to true aficionados: Check out the store’s higher priced collectible items. 16010 Detroit Ave., Lakewood, 216-521-6660, mymindseyerecords.com

Record Den
Sifting through the store’s massive collection of new and used wax can be overwhelming, but the shop has it all on hand because it eschews niches and aims to please everyone. “We try and have the deepest catalogue of everybody around,” assistant manager Victor Cooke says. “We take pride in having what people are looking for most of the time.”  7661 Mentor Ave., Mentor, 440-946-9909, facebook.com/recordden

Time Traveler Records
The store has a few thousand records, but owner Scott Shepard finds pride in being one of the last record stores in Northeast Ohio with a large selection of CDs, including many imports and hard-to-find items. “I think I have a really unique selection, with stuff that other stores don’t bother carrying,” Shepard says. 118 W. Market St., Akron, 330-819-8955, timetravelerrecords.com

The Vinyl Groove Records
In a new Cleveland storefront, owner David Wolfe says Vinyl Groove is “one of the stores that prides itself in specializing in everything as far as genre.” People especially travel there for its new and used selection of rock, hip-hop, soul and jazz. It's also one of the few stores that repairs turntables. 5100 Pearl Road, Suite 208, Cleveland, 440-439-8371, thevinylgrooverecords.com

Cleveland Magazine senior editor Annie Nickoloff contributed to this article.

Read more: Local Record Swap Events Welcome Vinyl Collectors and Appreciators

For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.

Cleveland Magazine is also available in print, publishing immersive features, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.