Some Cleveland Students Take a Gap Year After Graduation. Here’s How To Do It Right.

Travel abroad. Serve in AmeriCorps. Spend a year learning a language on their turf. Shadow a mentor in a lab.

For some students, the year after high school doesn’t begin in a lecture hall. It starts with a gap year, when exams and GPAs are on pause and learning happens in the world.

But what separates an empowering launch from a costly detour isn’t geography or adventure. It’s clarity beyond chipping away at a bucket list. The most successful gap years begin with the end in mind: a defined purpose and a concrete plan for what comes next.

“A gap year is not a delay. It’s a tool, but it has to be mission-driven,” says Teneisha Dyer, assistant dean for student recruitment and marketing at the University of Cincinnati’s College of Education, Criminal Justice, Human Services & Information Technology.

From a higher-education perspective, she says, the year must be intentional and structured, with a clear re-entry plan that ensures students return stronger, not stalled.

In Northeast Ohio’s college-prep schools, advisors say the decision to take a gap year is still uncommon.

“Maybe one every other year,” says Hillary Teague, associate director of college guidance at Laurel School.

The same is true at Hawken School and Magnificat High School. At both schools, students are in a mindset of matriculating on campus.

Those who do are not trying to escape academic rigor. They’re moving toward a goal.

“They’re really intentional about a certain experience they want,” Teague says. “They usually already have something in mind and are going at it from ‘backward engineering.’”

A gap year can be a smart move or a costly detour, depending on the student and the plan.

“It really depends on the student and how that time period is going to be used,” says Jessica McCoy, the director of counseling services at Magnificat High School. “Trying to make this decision, it’s important to think about the end goal. How is this helping you get to where you want to be?”

What’s a Real Gap?

The idea of a gap year has expanded in some everyday conversations. It could be interpreted as not applying to college at all, taking time off to travel or work, or taking a break. While on the surface, a gap year might spell freedom, there are parameters.

Technically, a gap year is granted to a student after applying and being accepted to a school. With this approval and a plan, a student can defer enrollment and dedicate a year to learning service or an experience tied to growth, Dyer explains.  

The distinction matters because timing impacts not just admissions, but money. (As for the gap year, students and families are on the hook.)

Also important, a gap year can affect scholarships and institutional aid, depending on the school’s rules and the student’s timeline, Dyer says. Federal financial aid is annual — families complete FAFSA each year regardless. But institutional scholarships and merit awards often come with conditions about when a student must enroll and return.

Her advice: Before committing, students should meet with admissions and ask how a gap year could affect merit aid, deadlines and eligibility.

“Every situation is different,” Dyer says. “It’s always best to meet with admissions counselors, learn more about the institution, their priorities, their rules when it comes to a gap year and how it might impact them academically and financially.”

Teague adds a critical technical point families don’t always realize: “Gap year” doesn’t mean you can defer admission to a four-year college and take college classes elsewhere in the meantime.

“That is not a gap year,” she says. “Then you are a transfer student.”

Many institutions will deny a deferral request if a student plans to enroll for credit at another two- or four-year school, she says.

What’s the Plan?

When a student brings up the idea of a gap year, the first question many families ask is simple: Will this actually help?

Cristan Harris, director of college counseling at Hawken, says more families are open to the idea, especially when students present a structured plan and a clear return.

“Most of our paths aren’t totally linear,” she says of the post-secondary journey. “Students gain a lot of confidence during a gap year, and their GPAs tend to be higher. They’re going into it with a growth mindset and want to start college stronger and more informed.”

McCoy sees confidence pay off when students use the year to test-drive possible futures. Many undergraduates change majors once they enroll. A structured year that includes job shadowing, internships or intentional work experience can help students “solidify their plan,” she says.

But advisors circle back to the same principle: preserving persistence toward a degree.

For Hawken students, the typical path is to apply during senior year, while counselors are still available to support essays and applications.

Then, for a gap year, they can request a deferral. There must be a good reason, and institutions can say no.

“In order to defer your admission, colleges will ask, ‘What’s your plan?’” Harris says. “You absolutely have to have a plan.”

From the university side, that plan must include re-entry.

At UC, Dyer says the expectation is a defined return term and ongoing communication between the student, family and institution. She recommends periodic check-ins, deadline reminders and space to reflect if interests evolve.

Because another truth about gap years is this: they can change you.

“It opens your eyes,” Dyer says. What a student thought they wanted at 17 may shift after working, serving or living somewhere new. Re-entry planning should allow for that evolution, not ignore it.

Dyer says students also should be able to articulate what they gained — maturity, clarity, skills; and how those experiences will shape their first year back on campus.

At the same time, counselors are also candid about when a gap year is probably not a fit. A gap year without structure can turn into drift.

McCoy is most concerned if a student struggles with self-discipline. Without goals, routine and accountability, momentum can fade.

However, she says, “a gap year with a mentor to keep you on the path can help a student stay on track.” 

Gap Year, Done Right

So, what does a well-done gap year look like? It includes structure, goals and real-world learning.

You need to work with intention.

Cristan Harris, director of college counseling at Hawken, says many students work for at least half the year — sometimes to fund travel, sometimes to build savings for college, sometimes to gain independence and confidence before they enroll.

Career exploration becomes a must.

Jessica McCoy, the director of counseling services at Magnificat, encourages job shadowing and internships in fields a student is considering. It’s one thing to “glamorize” a profession. It’s another to experience the day-to-day. That exposure can confirm a direction or save time and money in the future.

Service learning brings focus to the year.

From the higher-ed lens, University of Cincinnati’s Teneisha Dyer often sees gap years connected to service learning, mission-based trips and nonprofit work, sometimes abroad. Those experiences can translate into social-impact fields like education, human services and criminal justice. “It really needs to be mission-driven, not simply ‘I need a year off,’” she relates. 

For more updates about Cleveland, sign up for our Cleveland Magazine Daily newsletter, delivered to your inbox six times a week.

Cleveland Magazine is also available in print, featuring immersive stories, helpful guides and beautiful photography and design.