| West | South |
East |
| A Slice Above 8788 Pearl Road Strongsville, 440-826-1300 What We Order: Body builders pizza Angelo’s Pizza 13715 Madison Ave., Lakewood, 216-221-0440, angelosonline.com What We Order: Meatballs and banana peppers Dewey’s Pizza 2194 Lee Road, Cleveland Heights 216-321-7355, deweyspizza.com What We Order: Socrates’ revenge Dominic’s Santos Italian Restaurant 21467 Lorain Road, Fairview Park, 440-333-7437 What We Order: Smoked chicken pesto Papa Nick’s 11534 Clifton Blvd., Cleveland, 216-281-9191 What We Order: Ham and mushrooms Pelicano’s Pizza 2218 Wooster Road, Rocky River, 440-333-0558 What We Order: Bacon cheeseburger pizza Marsella’s Pizza 7425 York Road, Parma, 440-888-8400, marsellaspizza.com What We Order: Pepperoni Pizza by Robert 30634 Detroit Road, Westlake, 440-899-9750, pizzabyrobert.com What We Order: Taco pizza Sweet Basil Neapolitan Style Pizzeria 26235 Center Ridge Road, Westlake, 440-899-1899, sweetbasilpizza.com What We Order: Chicken and broccoli alfredo |
Angie’s Pizza 6932 Hillside Road, Independence, 216-524-8100 What We Order: Pepperoni and sausage Farinacci Pizza 9385 Olde 8 Road, Northfield, 330-467-7919 What We Order: Cheese Luigi’s Restaurant 105 N. Main St., Akron, 330-253-2999, luigisrestaurant.com What We Order: Pizza bianco Romito’s Pizza 6474 Brecksville Road, Independence, 216-524-8858, romitospizzawest.com What We Order: Pepperoni, mushrooms and black olives Teresa’s Pizza 520 West Aurora Road, Sagamore Hills, 330-468-8900; other locations at teresaspizza.net What We Order: Hawaiian |
Dewey’s Pizza 2194 Lee Road, Cleveland Heights 216-321-7355, deweyspizza.com What We Order: Socrates’ revenge Geraci’s Restaurant 2266 Warrensville Center Road, University Heights, 216-371-5643 What We Order: Vegetarian deluxe Guido’s Pizza Haven 12775 Chillicothe Road, Chesterland, 440-729-9666 What We Order: The works Guy’s Pizza 1838½ Coventry Road, Cleveland Heights, 216-397-9700 What We Order: Meatball, green peppers and mushrooms LaMarca’s Master Pizza 6643 Mayfield Road, Mayfield Heights, 440-449-1516, masterpizza.net What We Order: Master’s Popeye deluxe Petti’s Pizza & Restaurant 29303 Euclid Ave., Wickliffe, 440-944-1028 What We Order: Sicilian pizza Pizza House 3108 Mayfield Road, Cleveland Heights, 216-932-1200, pizzahouse1.net What We Order: Bacon and green olives Rizzi’s Ristorante & Pizzeria 2809 Copley Road, Copley, 330-666-1221 What We Order: Sausage |
The Honor Roll
Sometimes there’s nothing better than a slice of pepperoni pie from a no-frills pizza joint. Everyone has a go-to neighborhood parlor. Here are a few of ours.
