a slightly shrunken Chips Ahoy cookie
a very odd Christmas cookie
it was plucked out of a box of Godiva chocolates
How They Do It: It's not chocolate, not even dog-friendly carob. These seasonal truffles are a mixture of wheat germ, peanut butter and pumpkin covered in yogurt. "High in vitamins, minerals, other nutrients, it's healthy, but it's still a treat," Aldrich says.