Where Are They Now: Caila Quinn

The bloom came off the rose for Caila Quinn on 2016’s The Bachelor Season 20 and Bachelor in Paradise Season 3. But the 25-year-old Cleveland native, who now lives in New York City, didn’t give up on finding true love despite making it to the final three with bachelor Ben Higgins. A friend set her up with Nick Burrello, now her boyfriend. Quinn shared her roots while introducing him to her family in early October. She rented the Capitol Theatre’s iconic marquee sign and wrote, “Nick meets the parents. PS they love you.” “It was a way to get him to see the rest of Cleveland, which is the city I love,” Quinn says. “It was perfect. We took a walk to the theater and when he looked up he was so surprised.”